The Last Rites of Benjamin Hill
An Original Western Short Story Written by John C. Prejean Sr. / March 2026
CAMPFIRE STORIES
John C. Prejean Sr.
10/27/2026


I
The blood kept soaking through the makeshift bandage Ben created. He did his best to keep the pressure against his belly, but it soaked through all the same. As did the pain. The Arizona sun beat down on him. Beads of sweat ran down his forehead, mixing with the dust of the trail and falling into his eyes, the salt burning them. He was a stick of a man—barely five foot nine and no more than a hundred and thirty-five pounds soaking wet. Although at twenty years of age he had been living a life of crime for years, most of it petty, he was still green, a boy really, a mere child who had foolishly mistaken bravado for wisdom. He had taken a shot at bank robbing this time, which had proved him wrong, and now he was paying for it.
He staggered along the dry riverbed, each step weaker than the last, struggling with the sand until his legs failed him. His legs were shaking. He could walk no more. As he looked around desperately, he found no shade, only a lonely mesquite bush clawing at the dust at the edge of the riverbed, offering a measly shadow from its thin branches. He lowered himself as best he could, finally collapsing to the ground, knees first. The impact sent a lance of pain through him, sharp enough to draw a loud cry from his parched throat. He clenched his jaw and fought the pain, at last sinking into the sand, his breath ragged, the heat and pain unrelentingly pressing in on him. The fall made the blood from his wound pour out worse than before. He packed some sand into the wound in a desperate attempt to stop the bleeding, each pressing of earth sending a searing bolt of pain through his body, until finally, the blood stopped. He lay back on the sand in exhaustion.
He must have passed out, because when he opened his eyes again, the sun was sinking low and the sky was a canvas of purple and amber hues. His mouth was thick with thirst. He tipped his canteen, swallowing the last measly drops it had to offer. Empty now, the canteen slipped from his hand to the sand below; the hollow clank echoed in his head. Right then, the truth of the moment settled on him, heavy and inescapable. He knew that death was on its way. His shoulders shook as he wept—not loud, not wild, but with the slow, broken sorrow of a man who at last understood how little time he had left. He looked in all directions for his horse but didn’t see it. He couldn’t remember the last time he had. His surroundings had begun to blur from the fever and pain.
He forced himself upright, unwilling to lie there and become an easy meal for coyotes or whatever else prowled the desert after dark. With all the strength he could muster, he hauled his body out of the dry riverbed and onto the cracked Arizona earth, crawling, each movement an act of defiance against pain and death. He refused to die out there in the desert. He turned south and walked, knowing that the small village of Agua Fría, across the border in Mexico, lay somewhere ahead—a place he prayed might offer refuge and a miracle chance at life.
He walked for hours, or so he thought, certain he had covered ten miles when in truth he had scarcely made two. His feet dragged through the dust. He felt as though the land itself were trying to claim him. The moon was full and burned bright, giving him enough light to see his way. But now the blood—the blood started flowing, seeping through the sand he had packed in his wound, and his strength dwindled to nothing.
The night sky and the land before him swirled as if he were drunk; his knees buckled, and he fell hard and rolled onto his back, the ground still warm beneath him. He stared up at the stars, and his thoughts wandered back to his childhood, to the years before everything had gone wrong—before his father left him and his mother, and the house grew bitter and cold. His mother’s voice still haunted his mind, sharp and condemning as ever: You’ll never amount to anything, just like your worthless father. He was only eleven years old when she said it. That was the day he refused to remain there as a whipping post for her. So, he left home. The stars seemed to be swirling in every direction, the memories weighing heavier than his wound, and then everything went dark.
II
Only a day earlier, he had been in Blackrock Gulch—a high-altitude boomtown tucked into the mountain passes of southeastern Arizona, humming with the clacking of faro chips, a piano, and occasional gunshots. From across the street, he kept his eyes on the bank—a heavy structure of dark timber and iron, squat and solid as an armored box. He marked each man who passed, saw how their hands lingered near their holsters, sizing up the distance between them like men who knew how fast a mistake turned fatal.
Patience was not one of his strong suits, so he crossed into the saloon next door. The place smelled of sweat, smoke, and stale spilled whiskey. An image of hell quickly entered and left his mind. He ordered a plate of food and a drink, hoping the burn from it would quiet the uneasy feeling in his chest. As he ate, his back to the door, a voice came from behind him, low and knowing, and it made the hair on the back of his neck rise.
“I seen you checkin’ out that bank.”
The stranger pulled up a chair and sat close, uninvited. “I’m fixin’ to hit it too,” he said. “We should do it together. Split the take and spare ourselves some trouble.”
Ben studied the man in silence. He was well along in years—fifty, maybe sixty—with long gray hair hanging loose and a scraggy gray beard, stained dark from tobacco spit. His eyes were hard to see past the hanging hair; they were dull but watchful. They were the eyes of a man who had walked this road before and knew exactly where it led. There was something about the man, though, something that Ben couldn’t shake. He looked more like a warning than a partner, as if the devil himself had taken a seat beside him and was waiting to see what choice Ben would make.
Ignoring the thought, he turned the proposal over in his head as he ate, keeping to himself and giving the stranger no answer. It would be easier to hit the bank cleanly with two of them than alone, he thought. When he finally lifted his eyes, he saw the man more clearly and felt an icy chill settle over him. The stranger’s right eye was dead—no patch, no shame—just a milk-clouded orb fixed on him, unblinking, as though it saw something Ben could not. His soul.
At last, Ben spoke. “You follow my lead. We do this my way! You got it?” He wiped his mouth with a napkin and dropped it onto the plate, leaving the rest untouched.
The old man wiped the hair from his face, the dead eye still staring through Ben. “No problem,” he replied calmly.
They got up and stepped out of the dark saloon, back into the glaring sun of the day. At the door, Ben paused and leaned in toward the stranger, his voice lowered to a murmur. “You head that way, across the street near the bank. I’ll go back to where I was. Meet me at the bank at half past three. You do know how to tell time, don’t ya?”
The stranger looked at him, staring with his blind eye, which caught the sunlight, hard and wrong. “Yup,” he said, with a sly, evil smirk, and turned away, the sound of his boots fading in the distance.
The hour arrived sooner than Ben had expected. At half past three, he and the stranger stepped into the bank together, their faces hidden behind knotted handkerchiefs. Inside, there was a lone customer and the teller; the room was quiet enough to hear the ticking of the clock on the wall. The stranger locked the door as Ben moved toward the counter. “This is a stickup,” he said, his voice steady despite the nerves in his chest. “Hand it over quick, and no one gets hurt.” The Colt in his hand was trained squarely on the teller.
The lone patron—an elderly woman—caught sight of the gun, fainted, and crumpled to the floor without a sound. The teller’s hands shook as he filled four heavy sacks with bills and gold and slid them across the counter, his face ashen with fear.
It was over as quickly as it began. They gagged and tied up the teller and the old lady, grabbed the sacks, placed them on the horses, and hit the mountain pass at a gallop, leaving Blackrock Gulch behind as if the hounds of hell were after them.
III
After they’d put some distance behind them, down to the flats, and Ben was certain that no one was on their trail, he eased his horse down to a steady trot. “Where to now?” he asked.
The stranger slowed and turned in the saddle. The dead eye caught the last of the daylight, shining pale and lifeless, while the good one held a knowing depth that unsettled Ben. A crooked smile tugged at his mouth as he raised a finger and pointed ahead.
“That rise is called Purgatory Hill. That’s where we’re headed.”
Ben looked where the stranger pointed. The flats ended in a sharp wall of dark granite and scrub, jutting black against the sky. The soil was barren and sun-starved, stripped down to raw shale. Even the wind seemed to abandon the ridge, dropping off into a low, thin whistle through the rocks. It was a bleak piece of earth—the name fit.
The stranger went on, “There’s a cave close by. We can hole up there, stash the take, and lie low for a few days.” His voice carried an ease that felt practiced, too practiced and too calm for what they had just done, as if he had led men this way before.
The hill seemed to loom larger the longer he stared at it, less of a place to hide and more of a final reckoning. Every instinct told him to turn back and ride another way, to put daylight between himself, the hill and the stranger. Still, he said nothing. He turned his horse and followed. The stranger’s horse moved ahead without urging, finding the path as though it knew it well, and Ben rode behind him, still trying to shake off that odd feeling.
When they reached the mouth of the cave, the stranger fished a crude torch from a ledge outside the entrance and lit it. The flickering flame painted the rocks with restless shadows, and Ben knew without a doubt that the man had been here before. He followed silently as the stranger led them deep into the cave, the walls narrowing, roughly hewn, the air growing cooler and heavy with the scent of earth and stone.
“Put the loot over in that crack at the rear of the cave,” the stranger said, gesturing toward a jagged split near the back. Ben carried the sacks and tucked them into the dark, broken wall, letting them drop to the floor where the shadows swallowed them whole.
When he turned back, the stranger, holding his rifle with one hand, had it pointed at him. The light from the torch in his other hand danced in the clouded, dead eye, making it blaze like a piece of burning coal in the darkness. For a second, Ben swore it was less a human gaze than a demonic stare peering straight into his soul. The air thickened with the scent of smoke and something fouler, the iron tang of blood spilled long ago.
Ben’s hands shook. The weight of the stolen gold had robbed his fingers of their senses. He wanted to speak, to ask why, to plead, but no words came out. The stranger’s mouth curved into that crooked, patient, evil smile, and in it Ben thought he saw a vision of every misdeed he had ever committed—every lie, every theft, every choice that had brought him to this moment.
The rifle did not lower; the walls of the cave seemed to close in around him. The flickering torch cast shadows that writhed and breathed, like dancing demons bouncing off the stone. Ben realized, with a cold certainty, that leaving this place alive was beginning to look bleak. The darkness inside the cave, and inside his heart, was waiting. Damnation had arrived, and it would not be denied. It was time to pay his dues.
A flame erupted from the stranger’s rifle, the shot echoing through the cave like a thunderclap. An immense pain exploded in Ben’s gut, and he gritted his teeth, instinctively drawing his Colt and shooting. The bullet found its mark in the middle of the stranger’s forehead, and he fell, the torch clattering to the stone floor and sputtering out, leaving only darkness and silence where fire and life had once been.
Blood ran hot and heavy down Ben’s side, but he forced himself to stay upright, gripping the wound with one hand as he staggered toward the cave’s mouth, feeling the air coming from the outside. The night spread before him, vast and indifferent, the desert air tasting of dust, ash, and blood. He gazed down at the desert plain below, south toward Mexico. He could see the village of Agua Fría, the moonlight reflecting off the white adobe casitas in the far distance, the hope of survival. The loot could wait.
IV
The priest scanned the open plain, his eyes straining for the lone black sheep. He spotted it, off past the mesquite and sagebrush, wandering too far from the rest of the flock. The morning sun warmed his aching bones, and the desert air, dry and fragrant, filled his lungs like a blessing.
“There you are,” he said softly as he drew near. “Always straying from the rest of the flock.” He tapped the little sheep gently with his staff, guiding it back toward the others.
Then something on the ground caught his eye—a figure lying face down, blood soaking into the cracked earth. The priest’s heart tightened. He rushed over to the man and knelt beside him, seeing the wound and feeling the faint, uneven pulse. Ben was still alive, fragile as a candle flame in the desert wind, clinging to life by sheer stubbornness and will.
The priest returned to his flock, where his patient burro waited, its ears twitching at the sight of him. He led the burro back to the wounded man and carefully tied a rope around the man’s chest, enough to let the burro bear the weight of his injured body. The priest was not strong enough to lift the wounded man onto the burro. Dragging him would be the only way he could get him back to his place. Before setting off, he wrapped a crude bandage around the gunshot wound, hoping it would hold through the slow trek to Agua Fría.
He led the burro with steady hands, the little black sheep and the rest of the flock following close behind. Dust stirred around them with each step, and the priest kept a careful eye on Ben, adjusting the rope when it threatened to slip, murmuring soft words of encouragement and prayer under his breath. Step by step, the small procession moved toward the village.
They reached the old adobe church, its whitewashed walls quiet against the desert sky. The priest gently helped Ben up from behind the burro, took him inside, and laid him on the narrow bed in his casita next to the church. He moved quickly, boiled water, then headed out to fetch the local curandera.
Ben lay fevered and delirious, his mind drifting back to the years long past, to the rare moments of warmth in his childhood—before his father left him and his mother, and he followed suit, trying to outrun the emptiness.
When he stirred and opened his eyes, an old Mexican woman leaned over him with a damp cloth in her hand, murmuring softly to the priest as she wiped his brow. Exhaustion claimed him again almost immediately, and he passed out from the pain.
“There is nothing I can do. He is dying,” the woman said, her voice low, trembling with sorrow. “These hierbas and some wine will help ease the suffering,” she continued.
The priest guided her to the door, thanking her and blessing her before she stepped back into the sunlit courtyard. He returned to Ben with a small basin of water and a vial of oil, placing them carefully on the bedside table. He knelt beside the boy and began to pray.
V
Just then, Ben stirred, a moment of clarity breaking through the haze of pain. His gut throbbed where the bullet had struck, and visions danced in his mind like mirages over the desert sand.
“Where… am I? Who… are you?” he croaked.
The priest brushed the sweat from Ben’s brow with gentle hands. “You are safe. You are in Agua Fría. I am Padre Infante. You have been shot.”
Ben’s mind went back to the moment in the cave: fire leaving the rifle barrel and the impact of the bullet. His eyes widened with fear and resignation. “Am I… dying?”
Padre Infante’s gaze softened, somber and steady. “Sí. The local medicine woman could do nothing more. She gave me these herbs to mix with wine. Take a sip; it will help with the pain.” He held Ben’s hand, offering both comfort and truth. Ben refused the wine mixture.
After a pause, Padre asked quietly, “What is your name?”
Ben’s cracked lips moved weakly toward the water beside him. Padre dipped a clean cloth and pressed it gently to his mouth. “Slowly. Sip it slowly,” he instructed.
Ben drew in the water, and after a moment of struggle, he looked up at the priest. “Ben… Benjamin Hill,” he whispered.
Padre kept hold of Ben’s hand and asked gently, “Have you been baptized, Ben?”
Ben jerked his hand away, his breath turning ragged. “No!” he rasped. “I… never had much use for God. Seems he never had much use for me, neither!”
Padre Infante smiled. “God has always had a use for you, Ben,” he said quietly. “And He still does.”
Ben let out a weak, broken laugh, certain the fever was playing tricks on him. “What could he want with me?” he said. “I’m dying. And from what little I know about him, he wouldn’t take a man like me. I’m a sinner, as they say. I’ve lived wrong all my life—nothing but thieving, violence, blood, and evil.” His voice trembled. Then a look of fear overtook him. “That man… that wasn’t just a man who shot me. I saw it in that dead eye of his. That was the devil. And now he’s come to claim what’s his. Right!?”
A tear slipped from the corner of Ben’s eye as he turned his face away in fear and shame. Fear of what might still be waiting for him beyond the pain. Shame in realizing that his life had been one big lie.
Padre Infante took Ben’s hand again, his grip steady—firm with purpose, gentle with mercy. “God desires you to be with Him,” he said quietly. “He calls you home, to a place beyond pain and fear.” Ben looked into the priest’s eyes as he continued to speak.
He dipped the cloth once more into the water and touched it to Ben’s lips. “Every man is born bearing sin,” Padre went on. “It is the inheritance of our kind. God grants us free will—not so we may never fall, but so that we may choose to rise. You chose your own road, Ben, and it has led you here, to death’s doorstep. Now you may choose again.”
Ben’s eyes brimmed, the tears spilling freely now. “I’ve done too much wrong,” he whispered. “Too much to be forgiven. Why would God want a man like me?”
Padre Infante dipped the cloth into the wine mixture this time and pressed it gently to Ben’s mouth, hoping the warmth might ease his suffering. “Do you remember the parable of the lost sheep?” he said softly. “The one that strayed so far it could no longer find its way back. That is when the shepherd went looking—not to punish it, but to carry it home.” He smiled then, a smile worn smooth by years of faith. “He could have left the lone sheep out there to die, but he didn’t.” He paused and gave Ben more of the wine. “I did not find you by chance, Ben. God did. I am only the hands He chose to use.”
“But I’m dying,” Ben said, his voice barely more than a breath. “I can’t be saved.”
Padre shook his head, still smiling. “Your body, no. But your soul—your soul is very much within reach of salvation.”
VI
Ben lifted his gaze to Padre Infante, his eyes desperate and earnest. “Padre… I want to confess my sins. I want to tell God I’m sorry for all the wrong I’ve done. I don’t want to go to hell.”
“Very well, Ben. Do you repent of your sins, and do you freely choose to enter into the Catholic faith? I need to make sure that you are making this decision of your own accord. Do you understand?”
“Yes, Padre. I repent of all my sins and I want to enter into the Catholic faith.”
Padre’s face softened into a gentle, knowing smile. He rose, moving to the other side of the room, and lifted his purple stole from the table. He kissed the cross at the end of it reverently before draping it around his neck, then returned to Ben’s side and sat beside him.
He held the basin of water with one hand and scooped some out with the other, pouring it onto Ben’s head in three parts, each time in cadence with the prayer: “I baptize you in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost. Amen.”
Then, with the same reverence, he continued.
“The God of power and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ has freed you from sin, given you a new birth by water and the Holy Ghost, and welcomed you into His holy people.”
“I am ready to confess my sins, Padre,” Ben said.
Padre Infante looked at him curiously.
“You don’t have to, Ben. In baptism, your sins have been washed away. You are a new man,” he said, smiling.
But Ben didn’t return the smile; he continued to look somber.
“I would feel better if I could get it off my mind,” he said.
With a look of understanding, Padre said, “I will listen and allow you to get this weight off your chest. Your sins are already forgiven, but I will listen.”
Ben took a shuddering breath and began, his voice low and ragged. “I’ve robbed… held people at gunpoint… taken what wasn’t mine. I’ve lied, cheated, and stolen… and not just once. So many times… I can’t even count them anymore. I’ve hurt people… innocent people… and for what? For money, for pride, for fear. I’ve lived for nothing but myself.”
He paused, tears slipping down his sunburned face, mixing with the sweat and grime of the desert. “I’ve hated… so many… I’ve let anger rule me, let greed and fear lead me… and I thought that I could walk away from it all. But I can’t. I can’t escape what I’ve done. I’ve sinned so deeply, Padre, I… I don’t know if I deserve mercy. I don’t even know if I deserve God’s forgiveness.”
He looked up then, trembling, clutching Padre’s hand. “I don’t know if I was meant to die then, back in that cave… or if I was meant to live to face the truth of who I am. I’ve sinned so much. I’ve run too far. But… I want to… I want to be made right before I go. I want… I want God to know I am sorry. Truly sorry.”
Padre Infante squeezed his hand gently, nodding with quiet understanding. “God hears you, Benjamin. He has always heard you. Every wrong, every sin… it is not beyond His mercy. He washed them away when I baptized you, and He hears you now and sees what’s in your heart. Now lie there, and allow God’s grace to surround you.”
Ben’s shoulders relaxed a bit, as if a weight had been lifted, though the pain in his gut still burned.
VII
Padre Infante reached into a small wooden box on the bedside table and took out the consecrated host. It gleamed in the sunlight coming through the window. Ben’s eyes widened, a mix of wonder and fear in them. “What… is that, Padre?” he asked, his voice trembling.
“This is the Lord, Jesus Christ,” Padre Infante said, his voice full of gentle reverence. “He comes to you now in the form of bread. He has been waiting for you, Benjamin. He forgives. He loves. He brings eternal life to the soul. Ven. Ven al banquete.”
Tears welled up in Ben’s eyes, blurring the room, and for the first time in years, his heart felt light. The pain in his body remained, but the weight of his sins, his fear, and his despair drifted away with the desert breeze.
“Receive your First Holy Communion, Benjamin,” Padre Infante said as he held the host over Ben’s mouth. “The Body of Christ.”
Ben responded, “Amen,” and opened his mouth. As the sacred host touched his tongue, a sensation of warmth flooded his body, like sun breaking over the desert sand after a long night. His heart filled with the most intense joy he had ever felt. He closed his eyes, tears streaming down his face, and whispered, “Thank you. Thank you, Lord Jesus Christ.”
Padre Infante smiled, his eyes glimmering with tears of quiet joy. “Welcome to the banquet of the Lord, Benjamin. You are His now, body and soul.”
For a long moment, Ben lay there, embracing the grace of God, feeling for the first time in his life what it meant to be truly loved, forgiven, and held. Outside, the desert seemed to hold its breath, and the flock of sheep stirred as if witnessing a miracle. Ben’s tears of joy ran freely, and at last he felt at peace. His soul had finally been made right with God.
His breathing slowed, and the fever overtook his body. Padre Infante stayed beside him, gently holding his hand while offering silent prayers. The sun was climbing higher, allowing more light to shine into the room. The little black sheep entered and rested at Padre’s feet, quiet and watchful, as if keeping vigil.
Ben opened his eyes, seeing Padre’s kind, unwavering gaze. “Thank you, Padre,” he whispered, his voice barely recognizable. “I… I think… I understand now. I… am not alone.”
Padre Infante nodded, tapping Ben’s hand with reassurance. “You were never alone, Benjamin. God has always been with you, even when you could not see Him. Now, rest in His peace, Benjamin.”
Ben’s breathing faltered, each rise of his chest gentler than the last, until even the pain seemed to loosen its grip. Padre Infante and the little black sheep continued keeping watch; Padre prayed in silence as the breeze blew in through the window. Outside, the wind and the sheep settled as the heat of the day began to fade. Ben’s face, once hardened by fear and regret, rested now in quiet peace. When his final breath came, it left without a struggle, as if he were simply laying down a long, burdensome load. Padre Infante made the sign of the cross on Ben’s forehead and whispered one last prayer. In the vast desert that had nearly claimed him, Benjamin Hill was finally found and carried home.
© 2026 Wild West Catholic
Stories · Reflections · Journey


