Victory Without Humility: A Question of Character
Political victories come and go, but what do they reveal about our character? Drawing from Stoic philosophy, Catholic teachings, and personal experience, this reflection explores pride, humility, self-control, and the responsibility to hold ourselves to the same standards we expect from others.
FROM THE TRAIL
John C. Prejean Sr.
11/6/20267 min read


With another election behind us, the familiar reactions have begun. Some celebrate, others express disappointment, and social media once again becomes a battleground of political opinions, accusations, and personal attacks. While I understand the excitement of victory and the frustration of defeat, I find myself increasingly troubled by something that seems to accompany both: the ease with which we abandon civility when our emotions take over.
I say this not as someone who has always remained above the political fray, but as someone who has participated in it. As a former Republican who now considers himself an independent, I have witnessed the hostility from different perspectives. Over time, I became tired of seeing political disagreements turn into personal attacks, and I began questioning my own contributions to that environment.
Eventually, I decided to remove all political posts, past and present, from my social media accounts. Not because I stopped caring about political issues, but because I no longer wanted to contribute to the hostility surrounding them.
That decision led me to consider a larger question about the relationship between our convictions and our character. Political victory can become a test of character when celebration gives way to arrogance and contempt for those who lose. Through Stoic principles of self-control and Catholic teachings on humility and charity, we can recognize how easily our emotions and political loyalties lead us to contradict the values we profess, challenging us to examine our own behavior before condemning that of others.
Ancient philosophers recognized that unchecked pride in victory could expose a lack of self-control, revealing how external triumph can mask internal weakness. On this matter, Cicero writes, “Again, when fortune smiles, and the stream of life flows according to our wishes, let us diligently avoid all arrogance, haughtiness, and pride. For it is as much a sign of weakness to give way to one’s feelings in success as it is in adversity” (Cicero 93). Cicero suggests that success can test a person’s character just as much as failure, particularly when pride begins to outweigh reason. Gloating over an election win is no different than throwing a tantrum after a loss; both reactions suggest that a person’s emotional stability is controlled by external outcomes rather than reason. Seneca reinforces this danger in his Moral Letters, warning us that just as heavy crops fall under their own weight, a person's soul is ruined by “unchecked prosperity,” which people use “to injure others” (39.4). His comparison suggests that success itself is not the problem, but rather the inability to exercise restraint when experiencing it. When political victors and those who celebrate their victories indulge in contempt toward those who voted differently, they demonstrate that they have mastered neither their emotions nor themselves.
When political victors and their supporters use their victory to portray themselves as morally superior and treat their opponents as inferior, pride easily overtakes humility. In Summa Theologiae (II–II, q. 162, art. 1), St. Thomas Aquinas writes, “Now pride is the appetite for excellence in excess of right reason.” According to Aquinas, pride becomes a problem when someone develops an exaggerated sense of their own superiority and begins looking down on others. In politics, this can happen when political victors and their supporters express that superiority through comments and gestures that belittle the dignity of those who disagree with them. Such behavior is contrary to the dignity of the human person, which the Catechism of the Catholic Church teaches is “rooted in his creation in the image and likeness of God” (CCC 1700). Political victory may determine who holds power, but it does not determine the worth of those who supported the opposition. When that distinction is forgotten, pride can undermine humility and deepen the divisions between people who might otherwise disagree without treating one another as inferior.
A man’s character is revealed not simply by the standards he expects others to uphold, but by his willingness to hold himself to those same standards. It is often easier to recognize the faults of others than to acknowledge our own. When we condemn behavior in others while excusing it in ourselves, we create division rather than demonstrate accountability. In Matthew 7:3–5 (RSV-CE), Christ asks why we notice the speck in our brother’s eye while failing to recognize the wooden beam in our own. He instructs us to remove the beam from our own eye before attempting to remove the speck from another’s. Christ is not suggesting that we should ignore the faults of others, but rather that we must first be willing to confront our own. In politics, a man may recognize his own arrogance or disrespect yet refuse to change because he believes his political opponents behave worse. However, acknowledging his shortcomings means little if he continues to use the behavior of others to justify his own. Another person’s wrongdoing does not excuse our own, nor does it relieve us of the responsibility to examine and correct our behavior. Genuine accountability requires more than recognizing our hypocrisy; it requires the humility and willingness to do something about it.
Recognizing our shortcomings is only the beginning; developing the character to overcome them requires deliberate and consistent self-examination. Long before Christianity, Greek and Roman philosophers, particularly the Stoics, emphasized the importance of reflecting on one's actions and moral character. In On Anger (3.36), Seneca describes his practice of reviewing each day, examining what he had said and done without concealing his mistakes from himself. His nightly reflection was not simply an acknowledgment of his faults, but an opportunity to recognize where he had failed and how he might conduct himself differently. Centuries later, St. Ignatius of Loyola outlined a five-point General Examination of Conscience in his Spiritual Exercises (sec. 43), encouraging individuals to give thanks to God, review their thoughts, words, and actions, seek forgiveness, and resolve to amend their lives with God’s grace. Although their approaches differ, both Seneca and Ignatius demonstrate that self-examination requires a willingness to confront uncomfortable truths about ourselves. I would challenge men to make this a regular practice, particularly when their emotions or political convictions tempt them to justify behavior they would condemn in others. After all, what good is recognizing our faults if we make no effort to correct them? Marcus Aurelius offers a fitting reminder in Meditations (10.16): “To stop talking about what the good man is like, and just be one.”
In the past, I have participated in what I consider actions unbecoming of a Christian, much less a man. I would call out others that I didn’t agree with politically, sometimes stooping to the level that I detested in others: pridefully boasting, using profanity to get my point across, belittling others for their choices, etc. I started to notice that my frustration with other people who I disagreed with was influencing my behavior. I didn’t like that. After doing some self-examination, I realized that the only way to combat this behavior was to change it within myself. After reflecting on my own behavior, I began to recognize that I, too, had participated in the hostility and divisiveness I was criticizing in others. I came to understand that I didn't have to abandon my convictions; I simply needed to express them in a manner that was respectful rather than demeaning. With that realization came my decision to remove political material from my social media accounts. I was no longer willing to contribute to the hostility and division that I had grown so tired of witnessing. As a 59-year-old man, I realize that I can still change, still grow, and work toward becoming the man God created me to be. I think about the words Jesus spoke: “For what does it profit a man, to gain the whole world and forfeit his life?” (Mark 8:36). What good is winning an argument or proving a political point if, in the process, I compromise the very principles I claim to uphold? God has blessed me abundantly throughout my life with a beautiful, loving bride, wonderful children, and opportunities and gifts that I do not take for granted. I am grateful for these blessings, and I want to demonstrate that gratitude not merely through my words, but through the way I live, the respect I show others, and the integrity of my actions.
Political victories and defeats will come and go, but the character we demonstrate through them speaks to something far more important than the outcome of an election. Throughout history, philosophers and theologians have reminded us that self-control, humility, and personal accountability are virtues worth pursuing. Yet these principles mean little if we are unwilling to practice them in our own lives. As men, we should recognize that genuine strength is not demonstrated by belittling those who disagree with us, proclaiming our moral superiority, or refusing to acknowledge our own shortcomings. Rather, it is revealed through our willingness to exercise restraint, treat others with dignity, and hold ourselves accountable to the same standards we expect from others. We do not have to abandon our convictions to demonstrate respect, nor must we agree with someone to recognize their humanity. I am still learning these lessons myself, and I suspect I will continue learning them for the rest of my life. Perhaps that is part of becoming the men God created us to be: recognizing that character is not something we simply possess, but something we must continually strive to develop through our words, choices, and actions. So, before we condemn the behavior of those with whom we disagree, perhaps we should first ask ourselves one uncomfortable question: Have I become the very kind of person I criticize in others?
Works Cited
Aquinas, Thomas. Summa Theologiae. Translated by Fathers of the English Dominican Province, New Advent, www.newadvent.org/summa/3162.htm.
Aurelius, Marcus. Meditations. Translated by Gregory Hays, Modern Library, 2003.
Catholic Church. Catechism of the Catholic Church. 2nd ed., Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 1997. The Holy See, www.vatican.va/content/catechism/en/part_three/section_one/chapter_one.html.
Cicero, Marcus Tullius. De Officiis. Translated by Walter Miller, Harvard UP, 1913. Project Gutenberg, www.gutenberg.org/files/47001/47001-h/47001-h.htm.
Ignatius of Loyola. The Spiritual Exercises of St. Ignatius of Loyola. Translated by Elder Mullan, Order of the Common Life, www.orderofthecommonlife.org/spiritual-exercises-full-text.
Seneca, Lucius Annaeus. Moral Letters to Lucilius. Translated by Richard M. Gummere, Harvard UP, 1917. Wikisource, en.wikisource.org/wiki/Moral_letters_to_Lucilius/Letter_39.
---. On Anger. Translated by Aubrey Stewart, George Bell and Sons, 1889. What Would Stoics Do, www.whatwouldstoicsdo.com/library/on-anger/3.
The Revised Standard Version of the Bible: Catholic Edition. Bible Gateway, www.biblegateway.com/versions/Revised-Standard-Version-Catholic-Edition-RSVCE-Bible/.
© 2026 Wild West Catholic
Stories · Reflections · Journey


